
Episode 1100 • 52 min
Behind the Knife TSITE Review (Thoracic)- Benign Esophageal Diseases Part II
Share
DOMINATE the 2027 TSITE Exam with our FREE podcast review series, covering 28 high-yield topics.
Enjoy this sample episode from the course.
This podcast series was designed specifically to help you prepare for the Thoracic Surgery Directors Association In-Training (TSITE) Exam. All you need is a Behind the Knife account. Once registered, you will see the content in your Library. Track your progress, take notes, and access the material on our iOS or Android app.
Get instant course access: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/tsite-2027-exam-review
Additional Resources:
· Cardiothoracic Oral Board Review Course: https://behindtheknife.org/premium/cardiothoracic-surgery-oral-board-review
· Cardiothoracic Oral Board Simulator: https://behindtheknife.org/oral-board/simulator
Welcome back to Behind the Knife TSITE series. We are covering today part two of our Benign Esophageal Disease podcast. Uh, in part one, we focused heavily on motility disorders, manometry, lower esophageal physiology and pathology. But today, we're going to move on to another set
of high-yield topics.
These entities are ones that the TSITE loves, and we're going to look at things like classic barium swallow images, CT scans, endoscopic photos, management algorithms, et cetera, et cetera. Um, but before we go on let me introduce myself. I am
Kunal Patel. I'm one of the general thoracic and lung transplant surgeons at Duke University.
And with me today is Rebekah Boyd. Rebekah, do you wanna introduce yourself? Hey, everyone. I'm Rebekah, and I am thrilled to be back here for another episode with Dr. Patel. We're gonna be talking about everything that's labeled benign, but becomes not very
benign if you miss a diagnosis or choose the wrong management.
Well, that's exactly right. And again, things like reflux disorders, esophageal webs, rings, congenital esophageal disorders, diverticula, indigestion, corrosive injuries, perforations, and of course, everyone's favorite,
paraesophageal hernias. My favorite. All right. Let's, yeah, let's, let's get into it. All right.
The TSITE essentially is asking the same questions over and over again when we think about benign foreign gut stuff. Do you recognize this disease? Do you understand the physiology that's underlying? And do you know when and how to
operate? So with that, let's get started with GERD. Define GERD for me, Rebekah.
Well, GERD is what most people think they have. If you want a more technical definition, it's a pathologic reflux of gastric contents into the esophagus, and it has to lead to either symptoms or mucosal injury.
Uh, reflux alone can actually be physiologic, but if we're gonna actually use the word GERD, we're implying a disease process.
Right. So walk me through the anti-reflux mechanisms. Well, that LES that we talked about so much in part one with achalasia and your hypertensive LES syndrome that sphincter tone is
key but also your diaphragmatic crura, because they act as an external sphincter. Other things you have to consider are your intra-abdominal segment of esophagus the angle of HIS whether or not you have effective esophageal peristalsis, going back to our motility disorders, and then normal gastric emptying is also part of the
equation.
All right. And so how do those fail? What does that look like? Most commonly, I think, uh, we're thinking about transient LES relaxation, so when it's relaxed when it shouldn't be. Others would include, like, a basal hypotensive LES pressure. You could have impaired esophageal
clearance, delayed gastric emptying for a variety of reasons, and then you could have an actual anatomic disruption of the GE junction, especially with those hiatal hernias.
And how does that present clinically? Well, Dr. Patel, these are your patients who are going to come in with heartburn and sometimes a history of regurgitation.
And when you're talking to them in clinic, it's important to differentiate typical versus atypical or extraesophageal symptoms, and those include your chronic cough, hoarseness, someone with asthma-like symptoms or chest pain, and even episodes of recurrent aspiration.
Dysphagia, if that is a
symptom, needs to be paid careful attention to because it suggests complications, but it's important to note that you can actually have that as a common presentation for hiatal hernia, and so sometimes it's the only real symptom in a hiatal hernia Yeah. So when you're thinking of hiatal hernia you know, things like
dysphagia are definitely things that you wanna look for.
Uh, but what other complications does dysphagia point to? That would be your reflex esophagitis peptic strictures, Barrett's esophagus, and then the dreaded esophageal adenocarcinoma. Right. And I think before we sorta leave
the discussion of symptoms, I think it's important, at least in my personal opinion, to highlight that people with large hiatal hernias have some symptom.
You just have to ask the right questions. Uh, I think the idea of an asymptomatic hiatal hernia, uh, I don't think that that exists. I think that patients just don't
realize because they've been living with it for so long. So with that, walk me through the diagnostic workup. Yeah. I mean, if you've never known anything else, then you just assume what you're feeling is normal. That's exactly right So the diagnostic workup for uncomplicated GERD, that can usually be diagnosed clinically and treated empirically with
PPIs. But you need to be careful because sometimes this clinical diagnosis can actually miss something more serious underlying. So if you have persistent symptoms or you're considering surgery, you are going to need objective testing.
That would be your upper endoscopy, our friend esophageal manometry, and then the gold standard of twenty-four-hour pH
monitoring. Yeah. TSITE pearl here. So never operate without some objective evidence of reflux. Uh, you know, people with symptoms are gonna frequently present to clinic, but we can't just operate on them without doing some sort of further studying.
So before we move on from there, we need to slow
down a little bit and spend some time on the twenty-four-hour pH monitoring because the TSITE does love that. This is one of those topics where they're not just testing if you've heard of it, uh, but whether you actually understand how it works and how to interpret the results in terms of surgical
decision-making.
Right. Because that's really, as we mentioned, the gold standard for GERD Yeah, definitely. Right, so 24-hour pH monitoring, uh, again, gold standard for diagnosing pathologic reflux. And on the TSITE they'll often test this indirectly by asking which test you need
before anti-reflux surgery.
And the answer will be objective confirmation of reflux with pH monitoring. And they may try and trick you, especially now that the TSITE's down to only three answer choices per question. They may have endoscopy up there or, you know, a clinical journal of symptoms. But if you see
24-hour pH monitoring, just go with that.
Correct. Uh, all right, so let's start with the basics here. What is a 24-hour pH monitor actually measuring? And that's the amount of time the distal esophagus is exposed to acid, and that would be defined as a pH less than four over a 24-hour period.
And how do we position that probe? Very uncomfortably.
You place it approximately five centimeters above the upper border of the lower esophageal sphincter, and you usually have to figure that out with manometry beforehand. Yeah that detail matters. The TSITE likes to test you on that you
need manometry first, not only to evaluate motility, but also to correctly position the pH probe.
Yeah, and correct me if I'm wrong, but don't we have two types of testing now, both catheter-based and wireless? Yeah, yeah. So the traditional catheter-based pH monitoring
uses transnasal. That is the uncomfortable placement that you were discussing. Uh, the newer system, not that it's more comfortable, you're asleep because you're getting endoscopy to place it via the Bravo system.
And that'll stay in place for 48 to 96 hours,
depending, I think on the operator. But from a TSITE standpoint, you would say the principles and interpretation of both those systems are the same? They're exactly the same. Uh, they just are different ways of getting at that same answer. So now let's talk about that scoring system because this is very high yield.
What's the most commonly used
composite score? The DeMeester score, not to be confused with the DeMeeses score. I don't know that I know the DeMeeses score, but let's focus on the DeMeester score. What does it incorporate? It incorporates six variables, and I wish I had a fun mnemonic to remember these, but I
don't.
It's basically your total percentage of time with your pH less than 4, your percentage of time where your pH is less than 4 while you're upright, the percentage of time when your pH is less than 4 while you're supine, the number of reflux episodes, the number of reflux episodes lasting longer than five minutes,
and the duration of the longest reflux episode.
And I would really be interested in knowing who on earth came up with those as being the definitive variables. I think it was Mr. DeMeester. Dr., Dr. DeMeester. Yeah. Uh, sorry, let me just also say I now understand your
DeMeeses joke. Still not funny, but I now get it. All right. What, what's considered an abnormal DeMeester score?
Greater than 14.72 is considered abnormal and diagnostic of pathologic acid reflux. I tried to think of a way to make this, like, line up with pi. Like, maybe it would be, like, 3.14
times 5 minus a amount. I don't know. I just have to memorize 14.72. Yeah that number is absolutely fair game for the TSITE as well, and I think that that's just one of those favorite, you know, questions on the rounds and in the operating room as well from attending.
So just something important, I think, to commit to memory,
fourteen point seven two. How do we interpret the test clinically? Well, an abnormal pH study, that is a score greater than fourteen point seven two will confirm a diagnosis of pathologic GERD, and it supports surgical intervention if the patient's symptomatic.
If your score is
under fourteen point seven two, that argues against GERD as the cause of your symptoms and is actually a contraindication to antireflux surgery. Yeah, key point right there. The TSITE loves the question. Patient with heartburn, normal endoscopy, normal pH study. What do you do? You do not operate. Um, you manage medically or look for another diagnosis.
Yeah, so all right. Now, let's talk about testing on and off PPIs. When should the test be done off acid suppression? Well, if your goal is to establish or confirm a diagnosis of GERD, then you need to hold your PPIs for about a week, seven days before testing.
And what would you test on PPIs? This would be for your patients who are having persistent symptoms despite being on a PPI regimen. And so you're going to evaluate, to assess for maybe non-acid reflux or symptom correlation based off of their description. All right. So talk about
impedance testing.
What does that add onto the pH probe? Yeah, so a combined pH and impedance monitoring, that would allow you to detect both acid and non-acid reflux, and it does it by measuring changes in electrical resistance as bolus material moves through the
esophagus And when is that useful? That's in those patients we were just talking about, where they have persistent symptoms despite optimal PPI therapy.
And that's because PPIs will reduce your acid, but they won't prevent non-acid reflux like, like bilious reflux. Yeah. The TSITE may mention
impedance in the stem, but usually they're still just testing the basic principle objective reflux testing is required before surgery. So, Dr. Patel, if you were gonna sum this up as one bottom line sentence that we need to know about this for TSITE, what would you say?
All right. Bottom line, 24-hour pH monitoring is the
gold standard for diagnosing GERD. DeMeester score greater than 14.7 is abnormal. Manometry is required before probe placement, and a normal pH study is a contraindication to antireflux surgery. That feels like one of those sections where knowing those numbers really
matters, and probably most important is just knowing that 14.72, more so even than all those different exact numbers for the variables that I gave you earlier.
Yeah and it's exactly the kind of thing that TSITE expects you to recognize instantly. You know, that question should take you 10, 20 seconds to do and then
move on. All right. Let's talk surgical decision-making Well, it's my favorite topic. Um, could you narrow it down a bit? Just kidding. Indications for surgery would include refractory symptoms despite maximum medical therapy an intolerance of PPIs,
or complications that develop, like strictures or Barrett's, or the patient's preference because patient autonomy has subsumed all other principles of biomedical ethics.
Yeah. And so what is the operation? Fundoplication. A Nissen fundoplication, that's a 360-degree wrap, and it's
appropriate if your esophageal motility is normal. Well, what if it's impaired? Well, just like we talked about with your achalasia and your partial wraps after your myotomy, you would do a partial fundoplication such as a Toupet or a Dor to reduce postoperative dysphagia.
Well, I think for whatever it's worth, uh, I think there are a lot of
people, myself included, that just do a Toupet for everyone, as a matter of routine 'cause it is associated with a decreased risk of postoperative dysphagia with the same amount of anti-reflux prevention as a Nissen. So, I think you're not wrong there saying either a Nissen or a
Toupet.
Dor I would reserve really just for the context of a Heller or if you're a lazy surgeon, whichever one. All right. TSITE also likes a redo surgery. Uh, what are the causes of a failed fundoplication? I've definitely seen questions on this. That would be your wrap migration or a slipped
Nissen or a recurrent hiatal hernia.
You can get a wrap disruption from your partial wraps like your Toupet or an overly tight wrap causing obstruction. All right, what's the management of these complications? Depends on your failure mode, but it's often going to require a redo surgery with takedown of your wrap, and then you need to
restore your intra-abdominal esophagus, do a further crural repair, and then refashion your fundoplication.
And okay, before we leave reflux disease entirely, we have to talk about Barrett's esophagus. Extremely high yield for the TSITE because it's right there at the intersection of GERD, cancer risk, surveillance, and surgical
decision-making
and that's one of those topics where the details really matter, especially the surveillance intervals. Uh, exactly, so let's start with those basics. What is Barrett's esophagus? It's a condition, uh, named after Barrett in which the normal stratified squamous epithelium of the distal esophagus is
slowly replaced by specialized intestinal-type columnar epithelium, and that's usually a result of chronic acid exposure.
What histologic feature defines true Barrett's esophagus? This brings me back to my histopathology classes in med school, but that would be your presence of intestinal metaplasia with goblet cells
on biopsy. Yeah, and that distinction matters. Columnar epithelium alone's not enough. You need intestinal metaplasia.
The TSITE will definitely test that. So how do we classify Barrett's anatomically? By length. You've got your short segment Barrett's, and that's gonna be less than three centimeters of
columnar-lined esophagus above the GE junction. And then your long segment Barrett's is three centimeters or greater.
Which carries the higher cancer risk? Well, intuitively, the long segment Barrett's. Yeah. And so why do we care about that? What is the major clinical concern with Barrett's esophagus? There's an
increased risk of progression to esophageal adenocarcinoma, and that happens through the dysplasia carcinoma sequence, going back to histopath from med school.
And that progression risk is stratified by dysplasia grade, so walk me through those categories. You've got no dysplasia, low-grade dysplasia, high-grade dysplasia, and
then intramucosal carcinoma. Okay. So TSITE loves surveillance intervals, so let's go through them carefully.
Start with Barrett's without dysplasia. Yeah, so nondysplastic Barrett's, your surveillance endoscopy should be every three to five years.
All right. Now, low-grade dysplasia? Well first, it's gonna require confirmation by an expert GI pathologist. So once it's confirmed, then you're gonna progress to endoscopic eradication therapy.
All right. Important point there. So the TSITE increasingly expects you to know that endoscopic
ablation is now first line for confirmed low-grade dysplasia. Yeah. We can't just observe these folks anymore. What do we do with high-grade dysplasia? Well, high-grade dysplasia has the highest risk of progression to cancer so management is endoscopic eradication therapy, typically endoscopic
mucosal resection, or EMR, of visible lesions, and then that's followed by radiofrequency ablation.
And for some select cases, you may actually end up doing an index esophagectomy. And that's a big shift from older teaching, and the TSITE reflects that now. What about
intramucosal carcinoma? Well, that moves us into T1a disease, and you can find out a lot more about that in our fascinating esophageal cancer screening and treatment podcast episode in this series.
But if we're talking about it in terms of Barrett's spectrum, T1a
disease can be managed endoscopically if there's no lymphovascular invasion and your margins are negative. But again, esophagectomy should be considered for either submucosal invasion or high-risk features. All right. So now the surveillance schedule after EMR or ablation.
So that's every three to six months initially, and eventually increasing that interval over time All right, now let's talk about the surveillance technique. What biopsy protocol is used? That's the Seattle protocol. It's four quadrant biopsies every one to two centimeter
throughout the Barrett segment.
Sometimes I think of the Seattle Space Needle, I think is what it's called, and how it's circular, and so you can think about the quadrants. That helps me remember the name of the protocol. So it's the Seattle protocol. Um, and then you're also gonna do any targeted biopsies of any visible lesions. Well, I don't know how the Space
Needle plays into all this, but if that helps anyone remember it, then great.
Uh, it is a classic TSITE fact. But I will say from a practical standpoint, I don't think there are a lot of gastroenterologists that are doing four quadrant biopsies every centimeter for Barrett surveillance, uh, at least not from what I've seen.
But let's address now a common trap. Does anti-reflux surgery eliminate the need for Barrett's surveillance?
No, and that's important because fundoplication will improve your reflux symptoms, but it does not eliminate your cancer risk, so surveillance must continue. Exactly. So the TSITE
loves that question. Surgery is not cancer prophylaxis. Now let's talk about the risk factors. Who is at higher risk for developing, uh, Barrett's?
Um, you can kind of think of this as your classic STOP Bang patient also make it easier. So it's gonna be male sex, Caucasian race, age over 50,
central obesity, smoking, chronic GERD, and long segment reflux. I gotta say today, your mnemonics are going over my head, Rebekah-... but I'll try to keep up.
What's the approximate annual risk of progression from Barrett's without dysplasia to adenocarcinoma? That's about
0.1% to 0.3% per year, so it's actually really low. And you may not get asked that exact number, but knowing that it's low is in fact important. Let's talk about where surgeons come in in all of this.
Where does Barrett's become a surgical disease? Well, that's where you have invasive cancer that
develops or you have failure or recurrence after your endoscopic therapy, or when you require an upper endoscopy for oncologic reasons. So these would be your T1a with submucosal involvement and anti-reflux surgery may also be performed just for symptom control, but not as prevention, as we mentioned earlier, because it doesn't actually decrease your risk.
Right. And so what about strictures in Barrett's patients? Those would usually be peptic strictures, and so if you see a stricture on your endoscopy, that should raise concern for an underlying malignancy, and it's gonna require a biopsy and very careful evaluation All right. Final TSITE
pearl. If you see a question stem with long-standing GERD, distal esophageal columnar epithelium, goblet cells, dysplasia, what are they really testing?
Your recognition of Barrett's esophagus and then your correct risk stratification and your appropriate surveillance or intervention based on dysplasia grade.
Perfect. Perfect. So if you can do that under time pressure, then you're doing pretty well. Okay, now let's move on to esophageal webs and rings.
Start by distinguishing the difference between webs and rings, Rebekah well, webs are your thin mucosal membranes, usually in the proximal esophagus.
And rings are more circumferential, and they're usually in the distal esophagus. What is the classic distal ring? Your Schatzki ring, kind of like Schatzki's deli.
How does it present? Uh, you can no longer eat at Schatzki's deli. So you've got intermittent solid food
dysphagia, often episodic. This is, uh, kind of called the steakhouse syndrome, is another way to think of it. All right. Well, I'll take your word for that. What's the diagnosis? We're back to the barium swallow, and that's gonna show a smooth, concentric narrowing.
Um, that's the key there because if it was
malignancy, you'd probably see more of an irregular or eccentric narrowing, and your endoscopy is gonna confirm and be your treatment modality. And what is that treatment? Endoscopic dilation and acid suppression. Okay. Now, let's slow down, focus specifically on the management of esophageal
webs.
It's one of those topics that seem simple on the surface, but the TSITE will test whether you understand what's actually causing the problem and, more importantly, how aggressively it needs to be treated. Yeah, and these are very different from rings, even though they get lumped together a lot. Exactly. So let's start with that
distinction.
Where are esophageal webs typically located? Well, like we had said earlier, these are gonna be your thin mucosal membranes, and they're usually in the proximal esophagus, most often in the cervical portion. What layer of the esophagus are they involving? Your mucosa and submucosa only, and it's important they
don't involve your muscularis propria.
Right, and that matters surgically. So how do those patients with esophageal webs usually present? Progressive or intermittent dysphagia to solids. Liquids usually pass without difficulty. Maybe they just kind of slowly drip through like a coffee filter. And the TSITE loved the
association here.
So what syndrome should immediately come to mind when you think about esophageal webs? Plummer-Vinson syndrome. Right, and remind me of that triad. That's gonna be your esophageal web, iron deficiency anemia, and dysphagia and that association there drives the
management. So walk me through the diagnostic workup.
Well first you're gonna do your barium swallow again, and this time it's gonna show a thin shelf-like filling defect in the proximal esophagus. And you can use endoscopy to confirm, but that has to be done really carefully. Now, why carefully? Because
the proximal esophagus is narrow, and these webs can be fragile, and there's a risk of perforation if excessive force is used.
Although it strikes me that that could also just be a management technique. Yeah. So, uh, the, the TSITE may present a barium swallow image and ask for management. So once you've diagnosed an esophageal web,
what's the first-line treatment? I guess we're supposed to say endoscopic dilation, not inadvertent perforation.
Ah, correct, correct. So be specific, though. So you can dilate with either Bougie dilators or balloon dilation, and often even just a single dilation session is sufficient to relieve your
symptoms. Uh, but does that cure the underlying disease? No. It, uh, will relieve the mechanical obstruction and reduce symptoms, but it can recur, especially if the underlying cause hasn't been addressed.
Right, and that brings us all the way back to Plummer-Vinson syndrome. So how does that change management?
Well, it's super interesting because actually you need to evaluate these patients for iron deficiency anemia, and iron supplementation is an essential part of your treatment because in some cases, iron repletion alone can improve dysphagia and reduce recurrence.
Dr. Patel, let me ask you, do you know why? What's the mechanism
by which iron deficiency causes esophageal web formation? Yeah, I have no idea, Rebekah, and honestly, I assume that's just for the textbooks, uh, to keep in the back of your head. Someone can probably just Google it and send it to me via email at some point. TSITE does, however, love that nuance, that
dilation plus iron supplementation is the treatment, not dilation alone.
So are PPIs routinely indicated for esophageal webs? No, not unless they have coexisting reflux disease because webs themselves aren't primarily acid mediated. That's a good distinction. Now let's talk about
recurrence. What do you do if a patient has recurrent dysphagia after dilation? Well, you can repeat your dilation, and that's usually effective.
Refractory cases are rare, um, but those might end up requiring multiple dilation sessions. Any role for surgery? Not really. Surgical excision of a web is almost never required
and would only be considered in cases refractory to repeated endoscopic dilation or when another surgical indication exists.
All right, and another important TSITE point, surgery is not the first line for webs. So let's talk about cancer risk now. Patients with Plummer Vinson syndrome actually have an
increased risk of squamous cell carcinoma of the upper esophagus and hypopharynx, and that's opposed to your Barrett's and your peptic strictures, which are more adenocarcinoma in your distal esophagus.
Will that change surveillance recommendations at all? No, because there aren't any standardized surveillance
intervals. But these patients should be counseled about their cancer risk, and if they have persistent or recurrent symptoms, that should prompt you to do a repeat evaluation and biopsy the area.
Yeah, and if you get a question stem that includes dysphagia, anemia, proximal web, weight loss, that should
definitely raise concern for malignancy, uh, in that particular patient. Right. So the key management steps here are diagnosis with barium swallow, looking for that upper esophageal shelf endoscopic dilation, correction of your iron deficiency, and then vigilance for
malignancy.
Right. Summarizing all of that, if the obstruction is distal, circumferential, and associated with reflux, you should think of a ring. If it's proximal, thin, and associated with anemia, should think of a web, and manage accordingly based off of
that. All right, so let's move on now to congenital esophageal defects.
Not commonly tested on the TSITE, still good to know, um, just a little bit about them. So start with esophageal atresia and, uh, tracheoesophageal fistulas. Yeah. So the most common form is
proximal esophageal atresia with a distal tracheoesophageal fistula. What's the adult sequela of that? These patients are gonna present with dysphagia, GERD, strictures, motility disorders, recurrent aspiration, and pneumonia, basically a potpourri of all benign esophageal problems.
Uh, what's another congenital entity? This could be your congenital esophageal stenosis from tracheobronchial remnants or fibromuscular thickening. Diagnosis and management? Back to the barium swallow, and always remember, barium swallow first, then endoscopy. Um, depending on what you find, you can do dilation first
and then surgery refractory.
All right, let's move on now to esophageal diverticula. This is another classic topic because it combines anatomy, physiology, imaging recognition, uh, and very specific operative decision-making. So talk me through that.
Well, to start, there's three main types that we need to know. Your Zenker diverticulum, your mid-thoracic esophageal diverticulum, and then your epiphrenic diverticulum.
And before we go through those, um, what's the big conceptual distinction there for the TSITE, uh, that they want you to understand?
They want you to know if the diverticulum is a pulsion diverticulum that's caused by an underlying motility or functional obstruction, or if it's a traction diverticulum that's caused by external pulling forces.
Yeah, and that, from a practical standpoint, that distinction drives
management. And so let's start with the Zenker's diverticulum. Where does it occur, and what's the underlying physiology? Well, it arises in the hypopharynx just proximal to the upper esophageal sphincter through Killian's triangle, and that's that weak area between the inferior pharyngeal constrictor and the
cricopharyngeus muscle.
And that mechanism? So that's a pulsion diverticulum that's caused by underlying motility dysfunction, um, specifically cricopharyngeal dysfunction and failure, this time of the upper esophageal sphincter to relax, leading to increased intraluminal pressure during swallowing.
And how are those patients gonna present?
Same, hallmark symptom of progressive dysphagia. Uh, they're gonna have regurgitation of undigested food and halitosis. Chronic cough, aspiration, and sometimes a gurgling neck mass. Uh, I've never seen that clinically. I think I would find it very surprising.
Right. And so again, just like everything else in the benign esophageal diagnosis here is barium swallow, then endoscopy, uh, with, uh, pre-caution given to the risk of perforation. But what's management after you've made the diagnosis? Because this is gonna be where the T-SITE gets very specific.
Yeah. So the key principle of treatment here is division of the cricopharyngeus muscle.
If you treat the diverticulum alone without addressing the sphincter dysfunction, you're gonna get recurrence, and we do see a lot of those. All right. Well, now let's talk about size of the diverticula and how that
affects your operative approach. Yeah. So if you have a small Zenker diverticula, generally less than two centimeters, you can do that with conservative management or a cricopharyngeal myotomy alone if they're symptomatic.
What about a medium-sized diverticulum?
Uh, so diverticula between about two and five centimeters or your medium size are ideal candidates for endoscopic management, and typically with an endoscopic stapled diverticulotomy or a flexible endoscopic septotomy. And what about the large Zenkers?
Yeah, so this is the one that's
interesting to me because I always thought that it would be easier to do something larger endoscopically, but, um, actually for large diverticula, those greater than five to six centimeters, they're better managed with an open cervical approach. And that's also true for patients with unfavorable anatomy, such as poor neck extensions, who might get a question where
someone's had multiple cervical fusion surgeries or has C1-2 instability, and you'll paralyze them if you tilt their head back or something like that.
Right. And I think that the easiest way to think about that is that to do a stapled diverticulotomy, you have to be able to straighten out your neck effectively,
um, to be able to get that stapler in there. And so it's just something I think from a practical standpoint to think about once you get these question stems.
What does the open operation involve? Your open diverticulectomy or a diverticulopexy combined with a cricopharyngeal myotomy.
Right. And that myotomy is definitely the most important part. That's the stuff that you'll get questioned about in the operating room as well as the key to the whole surgery.
Why might you choose a pexy instead of a diverticulectomy? If your patient's frail or minimizing their operative time is important, the pexy will avoid creating a
staple line in the hypopharynx, and it will allow drainage by suspending that pouch superiorly. Yeah. So important point, do not pexy inferiorly.
Otherwise, you're gonna just create another pouch for things to sit in. The TSITE does love that nuance. So what, what are some common complications? So you gotta think about the
anatomic area that you're operating in. And so this would be a recurrent laryngeal nerve injury, a cervical leak, I've had one of those recently mediastinitis, aspiration, and like we mentioned, recurrence can be common if your myotomy is incomplete.
Excellent. So let's move on now to the mid thoracic
diverticula. Where are these located? Shockingly, they're located in the mid thoracic region in the mid esophagus, uh, typically near the level of the carina. What i- what is the mechanism of these? So these are your traction diverticula, so you can think of that as something applying external traction or pulling the esophagus
out.
Uh, it's usually caused by mediastinal inflammation, such as from TB or histoplasmosis, and that ends up pulling on that esophageal wall. Right. And are they true or false diverticula? They're true diverticula. They involve all the layers of the esophageal wall, and I like to think of it as this external thing that just loves
the esophagus so much it just pulls every single element of it to itself.
When then, what is their clinical presentation? They're often asymptomatic, found incidentally. If they are symptomatic, they'll typically report either dysphagia or chest discomfort, so pretty generic symptoms. All right. And is the diagnosis of this any
different from anything else we've discussed?
Not at all. Gotta remember your barium swallow and your endoscopy to follow. And then how do you manage it? If they're asymptomatic, non-op. Um, if they are symptomatic or they have complications like development of some kind of thoracoesophageal fistula or
bleeding, then you'll need to do a surgical resection.
All right. So what do you do if you do operate on this? You're just gonna do a diverticulectomy. So unlike your Zenkers or your epiphrenic diverticula, you don't need to do a myotomy because this isn't an underlying motility disorder. Remember, it's just
the love pulling that traction diverticulum out.
Uh, so in practice, though, most people would probably do it anyway. Right. I think, you know, we're all just simple thoracic surgeons, so try to keep it uniform. Every diverticulum gets an ectomy and a myotomy. Uh, you know, that way
we don't have to think too hard. So let's move on to an epiphrenic diverticulum.
Where are these located? So these are in your distal esophagus, typically within ten centimeters of the gastroesophageal junction. The mechanism? These are pulsion. So these are diverticula that are caused by
underlying esophageal motility disorders like achalasia or diffuse esophageal spasm, and you can kind of think of it as the, uh, esophagus is just getting so angry and pummeled that it just pushes away from itself and pushes out.
Yeah. And how do these patients present? Pretty similar to the others. You're gonna have your
dysphagia, regurgitation, chest pain, aspiration, and then probably the most important thing is to be able to ascertain the symptoms of the underlying motility disorder. All right. What is the key difference in diagnosis here versus all the others?
Yeah. So barium swallow is still your number one, but then you also need manometry in these folks because you need
to identify what the underlying motility disorder is. Right. So then how does that inform your management? Well, it changes things because treating the diverticulum alone is inadequate because that's really a symptom of the larger underlying cause, so you have to address the motility disorder as part of your management.
Definitely. Definitely.
So what will be the operative approach then? So basically, this is gonna be what you do for a motility disorder. So you're going to do a long esophageal myotomy extending across the LES and you're gonna combine it this time with your diverticulectomy, and then you'll do a partial fundoplication to prevent reflux.
Why partial and not a complete fundoplication? Yeah, just like in your Heller myotomies, uh, these patients have impaired esophageal motility, so a full wrap is gonna increase their risk of postoperative dysphagia Uh, what are some potential complications? I think these are common to probably the
repair of all of these.
This would be a leak at your diverticulectomy staple line, reflux because your wrap is not sufficient after your myotomy, dysphagia, and then recurrence if your myotomy itself is inadequate. Right. These have a high, high rate of leaking from that staple line, so it's just something to be aware of.
Okay, now let's move on to esophageal caustic injuries and perforation. Let's start with acid versus alkali injury, Rebekah. Yeah, so alkali agents cause liquefactive necrosis that causes deep tissue penetration, and acids cause
coagulative necrosis creating an eschar that limits depth but still causes severe injury.
And you can remember this because alkali with an L causes liquefactive, and acids with a C cause coagulative with a C. Yeah. I think on balance, you definitely want to
accidentally ingest something acidic way before something, uh, alkalotic. True. What are your initial priorities in the management of these patients?
So ABCs, just like always, airway protection first. You need to assess for laryngeal edema and respiratory compromise. Do not induce emesis or attempt chemical
neutralization. NG tube, any role for that? Generally avoided unless you can place it under direct endoscopic visualization. And what's gonna be the timing of that endoscopy?
Within twelve to twenty-four hours. It's contraindicated after forty-eight because you have a significantly increased perforation risk during that
period, which you'll have maximal tissue friability. Uh, there's apparently a grading system. I don't know why. Do you know it? I do. I don't think I've ever used it, but I can tell you about it.
Let's hear about it. It's called the Zargar classification. Um, grade
one is superficial injury. Um, your grade two, you're gonna start to see ulceration.
Grade three, you're going to have transmural necrosis. So your grade 2B and above predicts future stricture formation. How does management then differ by grade? Well, your grade ones with your superficial injuries, you
just do supportive treatment, and you can feed pretty early.
If you have a grade two, so that's your ulceration, you're starting to get blister formation, that's gonna require close monitoring and then nutritional support and delayed dilation if you have strictures form. And then grade three with your transmural necrosis, those patients often require ICU
care and then early surgical consultation usually a salvage surgery.
Yeah, and what's the indication for surgery in the acute setting? That would be your evidence of perforation, uh, mediastinitis, peritonitis, uncontrolled bleeding, or full thickness necrosis. And what operations might be
required? I know that there's a whole array of things that could potentially be done.
Yeah. But most commonly for the TSITE, you're gonna have to do an emergency esophagectomy with diversion in severe cases, and sometimes you may even have to do a gastrectomy as well, depending on the degree of gastric involvement. All right. So then what's gonna
be long-term management? So these patients are at risk for chronic strictures.
Those will have to be managed with serial dilations. If they get refractory strictures, that may require esophageal replacement using stomach if you didn't have to remove that initially, or a colonic conduit. And there's also a markedly increased long-term risk of squamous cell carcinoma, and so they
need to be put under surveillance.
All right, so let's move on now just to full-blown esophageal perforations. This is one of the highest mortality problems we deal with in thoracic surgery. What are common causes? Yeah, and it's also the only emergent thoracic consult that you get on the consult pager, so it's good to know about.
Well, that's one of the reasons why people choose thoracic surgery as a lifestyle is that there's only one real emergency, and it's an esophageal perforation. Which you can stent nowadays. Yeah, that's why it's so much better than a life in cardiac. Well, so most common causes, iatrogenic endoscopy is most common,
followed by Boerhaave syndrome and then foreign bodies.
You've got your trauma and then caustic injury like we just discussed. Talk about Boerhaave syndrome. What's that classic scenario? This is a patient who comes in, who had forceful vomiting followed by severe chest pain. They'll usually have a degree of subcutaneous
emphysema, mediastinitis, uh, mediastinal air on imaging, and rapid sepsis.
Yeah. What are those expected findings on the imaging, and how do you make the diagnosis? Yeah. So, um, you're gonna see mediastinal air, and you'll see spilling of, ingested material into the
thorax on the side of the tear. You diagnose that with CT scan with contrast is preferred, and you can also do a water-soluble contrast esophagram to identify the exact place of the leak.
Right. And the most common, you know, the pathognomonic is gonna be left thoracic leak, uh, for these Boerhaave syndromes.
Management here is gonna depend on several factors. What are they? Yeah. It's gonna be your timing since perforation, uh, location of the injury, the degree of contamination, which coincides with your timing, and the patient's stability.
Okay. So talk about now the management options. I know we touched on one of them earlier, but what are
all of the options at your disposal? Yeah. So that's gonna depend on the clinical presentation and your imaging findings. But if you have an early contained perforation in a stable patient, you can usually manage those patients non-operatively with strict NPO status, broad-spectrum antibiotics, and you need to include antifungal coverage, drainage
with tube thoracostomy, and nutritional support.
What are the operative options? You could do a primary repair with debridement and wide drainage, and that's preferred for your early perforation. And then reinforcement with vascularized tissue such as pleura, your intercostal muscle, or some omentum
improves outcomes. So what if they present the delayed fashion or there's an extensive perforation?
Yeah, so unfortunately, at that point, you're looking at esophageal exclusion and diversion T-tube drainage, or even esophagectomy in cases of extensive necrosis or malignancy as your underlying cause for the
perforation. And what will be the difference in management for a cervical perforation versus a thoracic perforation?
Well, I think you can kind of think about this in terms of how you manage your leaks, uh, based on your esophagectomy approach, too. But cervical perforations can be more often managed non-op
with drainage. Your thoracic perforations are going to more commonly require operative repair. Well, it should be clear, you know, drainage is still gonna be operative, uh, in the cervical esophagus.
It's just a different kind of operation. Yeah, like just a washout and drain placement. Yeah. And then the only other
thing to, to add in all of that, and I believe still fair game on the TSITE, uh, is that options as well these days include stent, as we said earlier. That's true. All right.
So let's, yeah, so let's move on now to the final topic. Classify hiatal hernias. Ooh, this is my favorite topic. You've got type
I, sliding; type II, paraesophageal; type III, mixed; and type IV, you have other organs that have also herniated. Yeah, so which types are dangerous, and why? II through IV, and that's because at that point, uh, you have a risk of volvulus, strangulation,
ischemia, and perforation.
So then what are your indications for repair? Any paraesophageal hernias that are symptomatic, and most asymptomatic ones in good surgical candidates. But if you have- Right... a patient who's symptomatic, but she's ninety-five, maybe you just treat the symptoms. Yeah,
there's obviously nuance there when age comes into factor.
But as we said earlier, too, I'm not a believer that asymptomatic paraesophageal hernias exist. So ask more questions until you get the right answer. Walk me through the operative steps. So you're gonna start by reducing your herniated contents. Then you need to do a
complete excision of the hernia sac, if you can find it.
Then you're gonna mobilize the esophagus, you need to achieve adequate intra-abdominal length, which should be defined as at least two to three centimeters. You're gonna do your posterior crural closure without hitting your descending aorta, and then you're gonna do your fundoplication. Yeah. So
fundoplication, I think technically in the SAGES guidelines, so probably the correct answer for the test.
Practically speaking, there are a lot of people that'll just do something like a gastropexy. I think there was a Jama paper recently on the Cleveland Clinic, that validated doing anterior gastropexies in these patients with large hernias. And so I think that
those answers are shifting based off of recent clinical evidence, but for the purposes of the TSITE, fundoplication, intra-abdominal esophageal length, crural closure, mobilization of the sac, all of those are the basic principles.
What about mesh, Rebekah? Well, um, you can consider that in large
defects, but it's controversial, um, due to erosion risk, and there's actually no difference in long-term outcomes. Right. So what are some potential complications from this procedure? Well, as always, you can get recurrence. Patients can get dysphagia, especially if you've done a fundoplication and maybe it's a little too tight.
You can get something called
gas bloat syndrome vagal nerve injury, and then esophageal or gastric perforation, especially if you let the resident do some of the dissection. Perfect. So if you understand the physiology, imaging, and management algorithms that we talked about here, you're gonna be very well prepared for the TSITE.
And so
with that, we're gonna conclude part two of benign esophageal disease. And as always, don't forget to dominate the day.
More from General
Behind the Knife TSITE Review (Thoracic)- Benign Esophageal Diseases Part I
EP. 1099 · NOV. 21, 2026 · 24 MIN
Behind the Knife TSITE Review (Thoracic): Lung Cancer Staging
EP. 1098 · NOV. 20, 2026 · 22 MIN
Inside the ACGME Rewrite: Trainees and Program Directors on the Proposed Common Program Requirements
EP. 1097 · NOV. 19, 2026 · 42 MIN
Colorectal Emergencies Crossover: Navigating Diverticulitis, Gunshot Wounds to the Pelvis, and Toxic Megacolon
EP. 1096 · NOV. 16, 2026 · 53 MIN
Clinical Informatics for Surgeons, Episode 3: AI in the OR and Beyond; Machines That See, Read, and Act
EP. 1094 · NOV. 9, 2026 · 35 MIN
